AI-Generated Rust Rewrites of curl Lack Hundreds of Recent Bugfixes and Security Patches
Large-scale, AI-driven Rust rewrites of the curl codebase have not kept pace with ongoing bugfixes and security patches in the official C project, raising practical concerns for developers about using or adopting these clones.
What changed?
Agents converted 185,000 lines of curl’s C code into 340,000 lines of Rust, creating unofficial rewrites of curl. During just over three weeks in which this translation took place, the official curl C project merged over 300 commits including more than 200 bugfixes and several security vulnerability patches. None of these updates, including crucial security fixes, are present in the Rust clones.
Why does it matter to an everyday developer?
Developers evaluating or adopting AI-generated Rust versions of curl need to be aware that these versions are missing recent improvements, bugfixes, and vulnerability patches found in the official curl project. This highlights a key maintenance risk: AI-powered or large-scale manual code translations can quickly diverge from fast-evolving upstream projects, resulting in less secure and potentially less reliable software.
What can the developer do now?
If you depend on curl for production workloads, the official C implementation remains the only version with up-to-date bugfixes and security support. Developers considering Rust rewrites for security or memory-safety benefits must balance those theoretical advantages against demonstrated gaps in maintenance and security updates. For now, if security and reliability are priorities, continue using or contributing to the official project. If working with or evaluating rewrites, audit for missing patches, and closely track upstream changes.
“We merged over 300 commits in the actual curl project. We actually improved curl during these a little more than three weeks. A little over 200 bugfixes actually. 200 bugfixes that none of those rust rewrites have. We also fixed a few vulnerabilities. In another month we have done another 200 and maybe fixed a few more vulnerabilities. Will these clones keep up?”
